Real-World Comps · The Cowboy Sales Process

A Live Case Study in Wholesale Real Estate

The following document is an analysis of a live case study presented to demonstrate a real-world approach to wholesaling and a strategic method for finding a buyer who will generate the highest profit. The case study focuses on a specific property in Atlanta, Georgia.

⁠

Key Players & Context

Jhon: The deal-maker, providing the actual details and numbers for the property. He closed the deal and is walking the team through his process.

The Problem: Vernon, a student, hasn't been closing deals, and we use this case study to show him, and everyone else, a winning formula.

The Property: The Numbers Game

Address: 2886 Alexandria Dr SW, Atlanta, GA

Initial Asking Price: The seller was asking between $185,000 and $190,000.

Zestimate: Zillow's automated valuation was $228,500.

The Cash Buyer Rejection: Jhon put the property under contract and sent it to his network of cash buyers. They all rejected it, deeming the price too high for a standard flip.

Why a Cash Buyer Would Say No: A traditional flipper would have to factor in the following costs:

Acquisition Cost: ~$190,000

Rehab Costs: ~$40,000

Holding Costs: ~$10,000 (taxes, insurance, utilities, etc.)

Selling Costs: 6% commission for their real estate agent

Wholesale Fee: Jhon's fee

The Bottom Line: For a cash buyer, this deal didn't make sense. The numbers would be too tight, and there was no room for a profit margin. Jhon confirms that if he had sold it to a cash buyer, his profit margin would have been significantly smaller.

⁠

1. The Strategy: Thinking Beyond the Flip

The Core Idea: Instead of finding a cash buyer who would flip the property and resell it, Jhon found an end buyer who wanted to live in the house and had a specific type of financing. This allowed him to avoid the traditional cash-buyer model and secure a much higher profit.

The Result: Jhon was able to make a "good spread" on the deal, meaning a substantial profit margin that would not have been possible with a traditional cash buyer.

Key Insight: This case study highlights a critical concept in wholesaling: the buyer determines the value. The "current market value" (CCV) isn't just one number; it's what the highest-paying buyer is willing to pay. This is a crucial distinction. A property's value is fluid and depends on the end user's goals.

⁠

2. A Guide to Calculating Property Value in Real-Time

Let’s break down a key strategy for real estate wholesalers: determining a property's value on the fly. We'll explore the "Current Condition Value" (CCV) method, the importance of quick, mental math, and a psychological technique to secure better deals. This isn't just about crunching numbers; it's about mastering the conversation and controlling the negotiation from start to finish.

Guide

Guide

1. The Core Strategy: CCV vs. ARV

Please click here to see more

2. Real-Time Comping: The Zillow Method

Please click here to see more

3. The Psychology of Negotiation: Anchoring

Please click here to see more

4. Why This Works

Please click here to see more

⁠

3. Real Estate Deal Analysis: Wholesale vs. Retail

Wholesale vs. Retail: The Core Distinction

The most important lesson from this analysis is that a property's value is not a single, fixed number. It's a spectrum, and the final price depends entirely on who the buyer is and what their intentions are.

Wholesale (Investor) Buyer

An investor, or wholesale buyer, is looking for a deal with a built-in profit margin. Their goal is to acquire the property at a significant discount, allowing them to account for renovation costs and still make a healthy return when they resell it.

Key Consideration: The investor needs to make a profit.

Typical Buyer: A flipper or another wholesale investor.

Valuation Model: ARV (After Repair Value) - Renovation Costs - Investor Profit = Max Offer Price.

Based on the discussion, the team's initial estimates for a wholesale deal were:

Renovation Budget: $40,000

Estimated Offer Price (E.G., Your "Buy Price"): $135,000 - $175,000

Retail (End-User) Buyer

A retail buyer is an individual or family looking for a home to live in. While they may consider some minor repairs, their primary motivation is not profit. They are willing to pay a premium for a property that meets their needs, even if it's slightly dated, because they don't have to factor in a large renovation budget or investor profit.

Key Consideration: The end-user is buying for personal use, not profit.

Typical Buyer: A family relocating or a first-time homebuyer.

Valuation Model: Market Price based on Comparable Sales (Comps) in the area.

In this specific case, the property was sold to a retail buyer on the MLS (Multiple Listing Service) for a significantly higher price than what an investor would have paid.

Actual Sale Price: $230,000

⁠

4. The Power of the MLS & Multiple Exit Strategies

The value of understanding the different types of buyers and having multiple exit strategies.

The MLS as a Tool: While a wholesaler's primary business is to find off-market deals, the MLS is a powerful tool for analyzing your options. The "comps" for retail sales (what properties are selling for to the general public) are often much higher than the "comps" for wholesale deals (what properties are selling for to investors). This is because the retail buyer is not looking for a discount.

Retail Value vs. Wholesale Value: The team initially valued the property for an investor buyer, arriving at a maximum offer of around $175,000. However, the property ultimately sold for $230,000, confirming that its true retail market value was much higher.

The Best Tool for the Job: AThe key is to have multiple tools in your toolkit. You must be able to assess the property's condition and determine the most profitable exit strategy. This means understanding:

Is the house livable? If a property is in decent shape—even if it's dated—and a family could move in with minimal repairs, it has a strong chance of fetching a high price on the retail market.

Is it a full gut job? If the property is trashed and requires a major overhaul (like the $40,000 repair estimate), an investor is likely the only viable buyer, and you must price it accordingly.

The Takeaway: The goal is to match the property to the right buyer. If a property is a candidate for a retail sale, you will make more money listing it on the MLS than you would by selling it to a wholesale investor. Don't be so focused on finding wholesale buyers that you miss a chance to make a larger profit on the retail market.

⁠

5. The Art of the Flex-Close: Turning Stiff Sellers into Paydays

The "Flex-Close" is a powerful real estate negotiation tactic for wholesale investors. This method is specifically designed for a seller who is motivated to sell but rigidly attached to a high price. The strategy involves conceding to their desired price, but in exchange, you gain a crucial advantage: time. This extra time allows you to find an end buyer, often a retail buyer willing to pay a premium, and lock in a significant profit spread. This tactic transforms a seemingly dead lead into a profitable win-win-win situation for you, the seller, and the final buyer.

The Flex-Close isn't about beating the seller down; it's about shifting the negotiation from price to terms. Instead of fighting a losing battle on price, you give them what they want and take what you need.

5.1. The Problem: A Motivated but "Stiff" Seller

A stiff seller is someone who genuinely needs to sell—perhaps due to a life event like a death in the family or a job transfer—but is unwilling to budge on their price. They might say things like, "I just need to pay off the mortgage" or "This is the number I need to live the rest of my life." Most amateur wholesalers walk away from this situation, writing the lead off as "not motivated." This is a critical mistake. The seller is motivated; their motivation is simply tied to a specific financial outcome, not a quick closing date.

5.2. The Solution: Give Them the Price, Get the Time

The core of the Flex-Close is a simple negotiation trade-off:

You Give: The seller's full asking price (or a price they're happy with, like $185,000 or $190,000).

You Get: An extended closing period (e.g., 30 to 45 days instead of the typical 14 to 20 days).

This negotiation bypasses the price argument entirely. You align with the seller's primary goal (getting their number) while securing the necessary time to execute your strategy.

⁠

6. Executing the Flex-Close: A Step-by-Step Breakdown

A Step-by-Step Breakdown

A Step-by-Step Breakdown

Step 1: Identify the Motivated but Stiff Seller

Please click here to see more

Step 2: Pivot from Price to Time

Please click here to see more

Step 3: Execute the Exit Strategy (with the extra time you've won)

Please click here to see more

⁠

Advanced Tactics: The Three-Layer Anchor

This is a clever and slightly edgy tactic for situations where you need to soften the seller's price expectations before you even propose your initial offer.

Enlist Your Allies: Have three different people—an acquisitions guy, a wife, a friend, etc.—call the seller on separate occasions.

Anchor a Low Price: Each person calls and offers a very low, non-negotiable price for the property (e.g., $90,000).

The Goal: The seller gets three low-ball offers, creating a "low-price anchor" in their mind. By the time you call and offer your slightly higher, albeit still low, price (e.g., $100,000), it feels like a much more reasonable and generous offer in comparison.

This psychological tactic can make your initial offer appear more attractive and can make the seller more receptive to your final negotiation, whether you use a Flex-Close or another strategy.

⁠

7. Actionable Takeaway

This case study demonstrates that a deal isn't "dead" just because cash buyers say no. The true skill of a top-tier wholesaler is not just finding a good deal but finding the best buyer for the deal.

Don't rely solely on Zillow's Zestimate. While it can provide a quick reference, it's not a definitive source of truth, especially in a competitive market. Use it as a starting point, not the final word.

Find alternative financing buyers. Explore options beyond cash buyers. This includes looking for buyers who can secure conventional financing, FHA loans, or other loan products. These buyers may be willing to pay a higher price because they are not constrained by the strict profit margins of a cash-on-cash return.

Expand your network. Build relationships with a variety of buyers, not just cash investors. Connect with people who want to buy a primary residence, especially in areas with high demand.

Practice makes perfect. Use this case study to practice running your own comparable sales analysis (comps)so you can do the work yourself and see how he arrived at his winning strategy. This is the only way to get "battle-hardened."

Want to scale your wholesaling business? Prexium gives you consistent, high-quality leads. Get your leads now 👉

The Cowboy Marketer⁠

⁠

Want to print your doc?
This is not the way.

Try clicking the ⋯ next to your doc name or using a keyboard shortcut (

CtrlP

) instead.